Just up Burnet Road from Pinthouse Pizza is Brooklyn Pie Company, which serves a more traditional New York-style pizza. Although the place has a few tables, it's mostly carry-out, with a walk-up counter for ordering.
I ordered a gyro, onion, green pepper, and mushroom pie. Overall, it had an agrreably crispy crust with a lot of cheesy goodness and abundant toppings. The sauce was minimal, but sufficient for flavor, and the gyro meat could've been a bit thicker, but had a decent flavor and complemented the other toppings.